In
June, columnist and lifestyle writer Malu Fernandez
wrote a story titled “From Boracay to Greece,”
in her column, “Fierce and Fabulous”
in People Asia magazine. It began simply enough:
a chatty retelling of how she spent her summer
vacation.
She
also adopted what’s become the boilerplate
tone of the new society columnist – frank
and a bit snide.
Then,
on her spur-of-the-moment trip to Greece, she
wrote: “To save on my ticket, I took an
economy class seat on Emirates as recommended
by my travel agent…. However, I forgot that
the hub was in Dubai and the majority of OFWs
were stationed there. The duty-free shop was overrun
with Filipino workers selling cell phones and
perfume. I wanted to slash my wrist at the thought
of being trapped in a plane with all of them.”
On
her trip home, she wrote about how she had to
endure her economy seats all over, “with
all these OFWs smelling of AXE and Charlie cologne.”
While she said “jetting from the Aegean
Sea to the Pacific may sound a bit pretentious
until you wake up in economy class smelling like
air freshener.”
And
in her column at the broadsheet newspaper, The
Manila Standard Today, she also wrote: “I
flew on Emirates via Dubai, completely forgetting
that Dubai is the hub for all the Filipino migrant
workers. Call me whatever you like but when you
are trapped in economy class that is filled to
the brim with migrant workers the smell gets a
little funky after nine hours of flying.”
Scanned
copies of the two-page magazine article as well
as links to her column in the online version of
the daily erupted in cyberspace. They were circulated
in emails, discussed heatedly in e-groups, and
spawned a virulent backlash in hundreds of blogs.
The
reactions, far-reaching, compelled a rejoinder
from Fernandez. In her newspaper column, she wrote:
“As I type this, I’d like you to know
that it’s not about whining, complaining
and bitching but just stating the facts. Just
recently, I wrote a funny article in my magazine
column and my friends thought it was hilarious.
It was humorous and quite tongue-in-cheek, or
at least I thought so, until the magazine got
a few e-mails from people who didn’t get
the meaning of my acerbic wit. The bottom line
was just that I had offended the reader’s
socioeconomic background. If any of these people
actually read anything thicker than a magazine
they would find it very funny. Most people don’t
get the fact that they need bitches like me to
shake up their world, otherwise their lives would
be boring and mediocre. I obviously write for
a certain target audience and if what I write
offends you, just stop reading.”
Needless
to say, the new salvo only served to fuel the
fire. Outraged OFWs called her piece “bigotry
at its purest.”
Others
got personal. Wrote one on the e-group of Middle
East-based Filipino journalists: “I would
like to call Malou a ‘BITCH’ but it
would not be appropriate for her, as bitches are
female canine animals, especially a horny female
dog. With the shape of her nose, she looks more
like a mother pig. Therefore, an apt title would
be a ‘SOW.’. But then, it would be
an insult to the porcine community. So, i’ll
still call her a ‘BITCH’...it sounds
and fits her better.”
While
much has been thrown at her in the last two months
including, allegedly, death threats, little is
known of her. She may have become the most hated
Pinay on the planet in the last couple of months
with Internet search engines returning hundreds
of thousands of results when you search for “Malu
Fernandez.”
So,
who is she? While blogs upon blogs have painted
an ugly picture of her persona, there has been
no attempt to write about the true Malu. This
article, however, does not attempt that. Rather,
it gathers pieces of information to piece together
what she is made of or where she came from or
why she is the way she is.
The
writer with an acerbic wit
According
to Gianna Maniego, her Manila Standard Today editor,
Fernandez started writing the column only in April
this year, upon the invitation of their editorial
board chairman Vic Agustin. And per her recollection
of the two or three times that they had met, she
could tell that Fernandez was “a very outspoken
and opinionated lady, but funny in her own acerbic
way.”
Her
editor also relates that when Fernandez was first
introduced to her, the writer immediately told
her to “feel free to edit her columns because
she tends to speak her mind and sometimes doesn’t
know when to rein it in; she said that’s
why she often got into trouble.”
Fernandez’s
style of writing, according to the editor, is
somewhat “stream of consciousness,”
adding that she “writes what pops into her
mind.”
“Maybe
this is why she often ends up saying things that
are politically incorrect,” says Maniego,
adding that she suspects Fernandez “deliberately
exaggerated her account in that controversial
column because she thought it would be funny.”
But
she is professional, her editor says, conscientious
about her column and cognizant of deadlines. “In
that aspect, she’s very professional,”
she said.
The
writer resigns
But
the brouhaha took its toll. Weeks into the furor,
Fernandez issued a statement announcing her resignation
from Manila Standard Today and People Asia. According
to Agence France Press, the newspaper’s
“editorial board has been bombarded with
countless hate mails from Filipinos all over the
globe since the article was published.”
She
wrote in her website: “I am deeply apologetic
for my insensitivity and the offensive manner
in which this article was written, I hear you
all and I am properly rebuked. It was truly not
my intention to malign, hurt or express prejudice
against OFWs.”
Fernandez,
said Maniego, did not talk about the controversy
when she tendered her resignation. But in one
of the accompanying messages to her column, the
editor says, she did apologize for any trouble
she might have gotten her into.
The
night Fernandez resigned, Maniego said, “She
emailed me and said she submitted her resignation
to Standard and then she thanked me for being
accommodating to her. I replied by saying I was
sorry things had to end the way they did and then
I wished her good luck.”
Maniego
adds that Fernandez seemed genuinely sorry in
her apology. “And I really think she had
no inkling she would be sparking a massive outcry
with her column.”
Any
lessons learned? “As for lessons, I think
the people to ask here are the editors of that
other publication that allowed her column to slip
past, because as far as Standard is concerned,
we vetted her column (with her permission) and
avoided the furor by exercising our editorial
prerogative. No harm, no foul,” Maniego
says.
A
more personal peek
“I
came… I saw…I resign!!!” went
a callout drawn over a photograph of Malu posted
in a Pinoy blog, the owner of which avers he knows
her almost all his life. “Our fathers both
work in the same hospital,” said Carlos
Celdran, well-known for his walking tours of Manila
(www.celdrantours.blogspot.com).
The
incident, he says, did not surprise him nor many
who new her. He writes: “If I was an overfed,
overcompensated, unwanted baby who was never as
pretty or popular as her older sisters and parents,
than maybe I too would end up bitter enough to
demand an advance on my inheritance and spew out
poisonous banter to no end. But I consider this
current situation to be completely understandable
in her case though. She really couldn’t
help herself.”
He
tells of Fernandez’s bad behavior as a result
of an entire lifetime of people around her condoning
it, but at the same time saying she cannot be
entirely blamed for the value system that she
acquired. Malu’s Friendster account says
she is 41.
”She
is a victim of a social/sosyal disease and the
friends who indulged her,” Celdran observes.
“After all, when she said her friends found
her article hilarious, I believe her.”
By
now, everyone must have read that Malu is said
be the youngest sister of the mother of Migz Zubiri,
last proclaimed senator in the May 2007 elections.
Is
she back?
But we may not have heard the last of Malu Fernandez.
Her column banner in the Manila Standard Today
read, “Divalicious will resume next Monday”
The
bloggers are back on defensive mode. “Why
is she back?” one asked and wondered if
the paper is “just waiting for the issue
to subside then go back to business (as usual).”
Will she be back?